Friday, May 3, 2013

Why Teachers are Important

Recently I have become aware of a new trend, college classes on video. The idea behind this is that a small local school can save money by firing their professors and simply buying video courses taught by professors. The students still get lectures and the school saves on the cost of hiring a live person. Win win right?

The problem here is that it assumes that the sole reason people go to school is to hear lectures. In fact, people pay to go to college to learn. These two concepts get confused because, in college, most courses are taught via lecture. Thus it seems to be an easy substitute to replace professors with video. The truth is that lectures are only part of why students go to college and pay such a high premium to do so. While it is true that 100 level courses are largely lecture, text book reading and memorization based. As a student progresses into higher level courses, class sizes get smaller and training becomes much more interactive. Classic techniques such as the Socratic method, thought experiments, lab work, and many others serve to teach students to think on their feet, apply the knowledge they have learned and learn how to interact with people. To reduce education to simple video lectures and memorization for tests misses half the reason students go to college. Learning is more than simple memorization, and to reduce it to such is a disservice to students.

A good example of this appears in the work of Charles Dickens. Much to my embarrassment I can't remember which book. But it's an indictment of the pure memorization education system. Essentially a teacher asks a student what a horse is. The student replies from wrote memorization "a four footed ruminating mammal." Then the teacher points outside to a horse pulling a cart and asks the child what it is. The child doesn't know despite the fact he was just asked to define it. The reason being that despite memorizing the correct answer the kid had no practical experience with a horse, nor even knew what one looked like. In this simple anecdote Dickens showed all the short comings of relying solely on memorization to teach students. Were the lecture the student was watching a taped lecture, he would not have had that interaction with the professor. He would have continued in his ignorance despite having the correct answer to the question. In short, the child would have continued on in his ignorance.

Also, from a practical matter, college costs a ton of money. State schools now charge in excess of $20,000 a year just for a student to take classes. Private college can cost $60,000 a year. More over, the value of a college education has never been more questioned. With record unemployment after the financial melt down of 2007 and 2008, experience has become more marketable than a degree. College kids now frequently graduate hugely in debt and end up not being able to find professional level jobs. So they are forced to live at home with their parents, work low level jobs part time and barely get by. For a school to reduce the education to merely watching movies seems to further cheapen the value of the education received. It becomes much harder for a working class family to justify the cost when there is no payoff in either education or in the job market. Instead of 4 or more years invested in a future, it is four or more years and tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of dollars wasted.

For a degree to have any meaning, the student must both have learned a lot of knowledge, and know how to apply it practically in the modern world. Reducing school to filmed lectures and memorization marginalizes the latter half of this equation. Were I still a student, I would think twice before going into debt to essentially watch a series of videos and have my grade determined solely by a few online computer graded tests. You don't pay for the lecture, you pay to interact with experienced college professors who are in the upper echelons of their fields. Schools should think twice before removing professors from their educational equation, because they may just find that they will no longer have customers.

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Deifying the 50's is Incredibly Stupid

One of the most persistent obfuscations in American politics is the continued misrepresentation of the historical phenomenon that lead to the economic and social booms of the 1950's and 60's. Republicans look back on that era and laud the stable family structure, wholesome family values and relative success of the economy. Democrats look back at the social activism, the high tax rates and powerful government and rhapsodize. Both parties refer to this era for their current political purposes and appeal to our success as a nation back then as some sort of proof of concept. The problem is that both views mischaracterize the era. This makes their analogies at best unpersuasive, at worst, down right misleading.

So let us harken back to the America of the 50's. It was a time of great prosperity, at least for white America. For blacks and immigrants from other countries, it was still a very unfriendly place. The civil rights movement was in full swing though. Martin Luther King, Jr. was advocating for minority and black rights and white America was finally taking notice and allowing the underclasses the freedom to join in the prosperity of white America. But such social progress was fitful and was often times underscored by violence. Also, America was indeed prospering economically, but the reason for this has as much to do with the end of World War II than it did any virtue of the politics of the era. After all, at the end of World War II, Europe was a bombed out mess, Japan had been nuked, and the cold war between the two largest economies that were not destroyed by the war (the USA and the USSR) was just heating up. This meant that, in the western world, only the USA was left as a provider and manufacturer of goods for a rapidly rebuilding and healing Europe. Once the 60's were over and Europe and Japan were beginning to reach parity with the USA in manufacturing and business, the economy tanked. There were a variety of reasons, the 1973 oil crisis, the failure of the Bretton Woods method of monetary management; but overlooked among these reasons usually is the fact that the USA suddenly had competition from the rest of the world in manufacturing. This competition put strong downward pressure on wages. Manufacturers started to fail all over the USA, unable to compete with the new competition from abroad. It was not till the Reagan era and the Thatcher era that the old system was junked, that taxes were lowered, that capital markets were opened up, that the economy really turned around.

So now let us deal with the Republican's vision of the 50's. As I said above, they laud the 50's for its stable families, prosperity and family values. But as I point out above, this safety and stability only existed if you were white (and since most Republicans are white, it gives them a skewed perspective on events). Also worth noting was the divorce system of that era was a fault based system. You had to have a real demonstrable reason to divorce someone, not liking the person anymore just wouldn't cut the mustard. While courts would rarely force two people to stay together if they no longer wanted to, they did not make it easy for them either. The end result is that, under the veneer of the happy family and lower divorce rate, was a seedier reality. Realities like couples staying together because they couldn't afford a lawyer to gin up a proper at fault reason for them to divorce, or spousal abuse and spousal rapes going unreported because a paternalistic society tended to ignore the complaints made by women. The family may have looked happy from the outside, but the reality was often much grimmer. Regardless, holding the 50's up as some paragon of family values misses the point entirely. The society of the time was just very good at hiding its problems.

The Democrats' view of this era is equally specious. They laud the powerful unions, the high tax rates on the rich and the prosperity of the nation at that time. Presumably, they use it as a model for their current tax and spend agenda. What they ignore is that it was only because of the unique properties of that era that expensive labor, high taxes and unionization didn't bankrupt the nation. As I said above, after WWII, the USA was the only first world nation (other than the USSR) that still had a manufacturing base and healthy economy. The result was that we provided the goods that allowed Europe and Japan to rebuild. Once they had rebuilt, and our industries had to compete on the open market, many of them failed. When they failed, the confiscatory tax rates on the wealthy overly burdened the economy and slowed our recovery. The reality was then, and still is now, that high taxes, organized labor and statist policies bankrupt the nation and make our products uncompetitive on the world market. They only were able to flourish because we had no competition. A reality that no longer exists.

So, in short, let us stop harkening back to the 50's as some sort of model for modern America. Except as a cautionary tale, it has absolutely no relevance on current political and economic problems. Also, do not let yourself be convinced by references to the 50's and the ensuing arguments from analogy to it. Arguments by analogy are formal logic fallacies and the reality of the 50's renders the comparison unpersuasive (even if you accept arguments by analogy as persuasive).

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Thatcher, and the Beauty of Smaller Government

This week a legend in British Politics passed away. Margaret Thatcher died on April 8th from a stroke after a long decline in health that limited her public appearances in the last years of her life. Perhaps second only to Winston Churchill in modern British Politics, Mrs. Thatcher's influence and impact is unquestionable. She took office in 1979, during a time of great political unrest in Britain. Unions had taken over, the top tax rate was a confiscatory 83%, inflation had reached double digits, public expenditures were 42% of British GDP and the British government accounted for 30% of the work force. The previous two Labour governments lead By Messrs. Heath and Wilson had tipped political power so far towards the unions that the popular consensus of the time was that Britain was ungovernable.

To right the proverbial sinking ship, Mrs. Thatcher took on the unions, lowered taxes (from the above mentioned 83% to 40%), privatized loss leading government run industries and tightly controlled the monetary supply to battle inflation. Her actions likely saved Britain from bankruptcy, and certainly turned the economy around. Under her care, Britain moved from being the 6th largest world economy to 4th largest; and this during a time when most economies were expanding (in most cases, because they followed a similar small government approach).

While this is interesting from a historical perspective, it serves as a good example and a good reminder to current world governments that the path to economic expansion is well known. We may live in different times than Mrs. Thatcher governed, but there are certain undeniable parallels. First, governments have expanded markedly, so has government debt, and the entire banking system has become a ward of the various states. Unions' pay packages, benefits and pensions have grown beyond what most Americans earn in the free market. More over, those pensions are beginning to bankrupt state governments (at least here in America). Instead of raising taxes, we have resorted to deficit spending and printing money to finance the excesses of our governments. This has lead us to a period of persistent unemployment, the lowest labor participation rate since 1979 (the year Mrs. Thatcher took office) and high levels of underemployment. Meanwhile current governments are flailing around unable, or unwilling, to do what is needed to right the ship.

The modern era could well use a Margaret Thatcher. We need a charismatic leader to step in, be the adult in the room, and give our economies and politics the medicine they need. We need someone to take on the public employee unions that are bankrupting us and draining money away from infrastructure projects that would better grow our economy in the long run. We need someone to take on the tax and spend cultures that have invaded the modern first world. Someone to come in and let the citizens keep more of their paychecks to stimulate the economy with. We need someone to instill tighter fiscal policies on our various central banks so that we stop debasing our currencies and penalizing savers. We need someone to privatize the banking system again, cutting off access to the central banks' borrowing windows to investment firms (reinacting Glass-Steagall here in the US would be a good way to do this, ditto ending too big to fail). In short, we could use a dose of Thatcherism in the modern era.

Here is a clip of the Iron Lady lambasting Labour for harping on a wage gap while ignoring the increase in welfare of the poorest members of Britain.

http://youtu.be/okHGCz6xxiw

Here is a bonus quote from the Iron Lady on the profligacy of Socialist governments: "Socialist governments traditionally do make a financial mess. They always run out of other people's money."

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Modern Feudalism

One of the advantages of modern society is the apparent freedom that we all enjoy. We can move freely between states (or provinces, depending on where you live) and relatively freely between countries. We can even move to another country, buy property and permanently immigrate there (following the laws of both countries governing such movements). We can work in whatever profession we prefer and spend our money as we see fit. In many ways we live in a very fortunate time.

In political theory arenas, our current system is called capitalism. The belief that the free flow of capital and labor lead to the best possible allocation of resources. In order to achieve this free flow of labor and capital we allow for private ownership of property. It is, however, important to remember that this was not always the case. The idea of private ownership of property and capital is a relatively new one. Capitalism, our modern system, grew out of the feudal system.

In the dark ages, all land was owned by the liege lord, who ruled through what was believed to be a divine right. The king was the chosen of god, and owned all property. He then divided up his lands among his subordinates, his lords, to rule the various parts of his kingdoms. These lords had vassals, and the vassals ran local towns. The common folk were viewed as being tied to the land they were born in, and worked for their own sustenance and the sustenance of their liege lords. Free flow of labor was not allowed, and the liege lord had absolute power over his particular fiefdom. The people provided labor and goods to the lord, the lord then provided for military and police protections to the citizens.

As society developed, professions did as well. Farming communities began specializing their labor to better use their time. Millers, coopers, black smiths and many other professions developed and improved society. As the professions developed and formed guilds, and these guilds started controlling larger and larger amounts of money. They became a second class that existed between the lords and the farmers. A middle class of professionals who lived in cities and worked for money. As this portion of the economy grew, the traditional lords, who were dependent on the money of the middle class and the population of the lower class to maintain its military and police powers, found themselves subordinate to the middle class. This lead to all sorts of class struggles. The end result was the old feudal system gave way to representative democracy, where the rulers who controlled the military and police powers of the state, were controlled by elected officials beholden to the general public.

The one constant between feudal times and current ones is the means by which the state, or liege lords, collected their due of the fruits of the labors of the general population. This is through taxes. In feudal times, farmers gave part of their crops to the lord and, in war times, they were expected to show up and be armed as part of the levies that defended the kingdom. Once the middle class developed, they paid their lord in the form of a percentage of profits, and rent on the land they were using for their businesses (all lands being owned by their liege lord). In the modern era, we pay our governments a portion of our salaries, property taxes and a variety of other taxes that have been dreamed up over the intervening years. Also, in times of war, people may still be "drafted" into the military to help defend their country and its interests.

So, now that we have gotten the history lesson out of the way, you may be wondering what the point of this article is. My point is to show how little has actually changed in the ensuing years. During the feudal era, the populace was kept in line and tied to the land by the liege lord. In the modern era, we are no longer tied to a particular state, but we are still controlled by whatever state we choose to live in. We may now have a say in government by being allowed to vote on who represents us. But given the cost and complexity of the modern political process, these contests are fought between professional candidates backed by entrenched political parties. We get two, maybe three, choices for any office, all of whom are controlled by their respective political parties. The parties are themselves heavily invested in the system that gives them power, that lets them exert control on the general populace. So while we can steer government to some degree, our actual power to change the system is quite small. More over, our current government still has the ability to call us into serve the military through the general draft. The draft is, after all, not so different from calling in the feudal levies. Worse, the modern government of a first world nation has unprecedented powers in running the lives of its populace. Feudal lords did not run schools or control the curriculum of what was taught to their subjects. The only indoctrination was done by the church, and then only on the sabbath. They couldn't monitor their subjects with a networked system of cameras in feudal times either. The tools by which government exerts control over us now were unheard of and unimagined during the feudal era. The one key difference, and it is a large difference, is that these powers are held in check by our ability to vote public officials out of office. This helps to avoid the worst abuses that such a system could be used for. A power not enjoyed by those who lived in the feudal era. It still does not change the fact that our modern, enlightened. governments exert much greater control over all aspects of our lives than the feudal one did on its subjects.

This is why I call this article modern feudalism. In the modern era we are still viewed by our governments as a mere source of revenue. We are subject to an unprecedented amount of taxes. Our hopes and dreams are only important to our liege lords on election day. Our powers too weak and disparate to enact true change and remove entrenched interests from the reins of power. We may have inalienable rights, but we have many less freedoms now than we did back then. The one key difference is that we have rights now. There are political ramifications for intruding on them. So the worst abuses of the populace of the feudal era (and the sexual liberties that the authorities took with their subjects) are no longer problems. Instead we live in a whole new world of government monitoring and government control of our actions. So the liberties that the government does take, it does so on a much larger scale. This is modern feudalism.

Friday, March 8, 2013

The Problem With Data

In the modern world, where much of all human interaction is stored and recorded in some way on computers, data about every aspect of our lives is available for public consumption in ways that, even a generation ago, we never thought was possible. This creates problems, first for society, and second, for the individual. For society, because there is no consensus on what is the proper use for this data (morally and ethically speaking), and no consensus over what, if any, laws we should enact to govern the use of this data. For the individual, because he or she does not always know, or is aware of, what data is being shared about themselves publicly and what that data is being used for. The end result has been that many people are surprised to learn what advertisers, or even employers, are able to find out about them through data mining.

For a practical discussion of this, let's look at Facebook. Facebook, for those who have spent the last decade in an arctic wilderness devoid of internet accessibility, is a social web site where people create pages about themselves and their lives and share them with their friends. At first this started as just a social networking site. As the company behind it grew, it started adding advertising, games, marketing, and other features to capitalize on its user base. Today Facebook data mines all the posts and pictures people put on it to bombard them with targeted advertising. It is so good that based on benign information you share, it can tell very intimate things about you. For example this article: http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-target-figured-out-a-teen-girl-was-pregnant-before-her-father-did/.

More alarmingly, employers and health insurance providers have begun buying your purchasing habits from credit card companies and major retailers in order to monitor whether or not you are living a healthy lifestyle. They believe this is a necessary step in keeping medical costs down and keeping people healthy and productive. It also gives them the ability to target wellness programs to benefit both themselves and, presumably, the employees. The counter argument is that this breaks the boundary between one's personal and professional lives and is a violation of an employee's privacy. See this article: http://www.marketwatch.com/story/is-your-company-watching-your-weight-2013-02-25.
But the reality is, based on available information, employers are able to learn a lot more about you than previous generations. There are also some fairly significant legal issues that go along with adopting such policies, and both employers and employees should be wary of trodding on the rights of people protected by various laws (think Americans with Disabilities Act, hostile work place and discrimination suits).

The end result is that we already have to worry about embarrassing Facebook posts or pictures keeping people from getting jobs, employers targeting employees for health counseling based on purchasing habits, or even employers making adverse employment decision about people based on data mining. The future could get even less private with employers monitoring all aspects of employees' lives to help them be more productive employees. If you hate a boss who micromanages your work, how will you feel when he or she micromanages your personal life, purchasing decisions and even dietary choices? The result of unregulated data usage could very well lead to just such a result. How long before employers can monitor your every move through your cell phone? It already logs your position with GPS and tower triangulation, and your activity based on accelerometers and G-meters.

The end result is that, as technology matures and innovations are made, we as a country (or as a world really) need to create clear legal frameworks for the use of this new world of freely available data. If a society decides that the division between public and private, professional and social, are divisions that should be nurtured, it will need to create a regulatory structure that fosters such results. Otherwise, the future of data mining could well lead to a pseudo Orwellian future where big brother and big employers monitor your every move. Until such framework exists, it's a good idea to be as careful as you can be about what data you are sharing.


Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Sweet Sequester

Currently one of the biggest news items nationally in the USA is that of the upcoming US federal budget cuts commonly referred to as sequester. Sequestration is a product of the 2011 budget deal. Part of that bill was a requirement that a bipartisan committee come up with a plan to cut the budget. If it failed, this would trigger a series of automatic budget cuts called sequestration. The result is about a 5% cut to domestic spending and a 7% cut to our military, or about an $85 billion cut from the annual budget, or about 2.3% of total government spending.

The democrats are railing against these budget cuts because they feel it will cut essential services and harm our economy. War hawk republicans are railing against the cuts because they think it will degrade our military readiness. The resulting shrieks are being replayed in both left leaning and right leaning news outlets. The irony of this is that government (many of those same politicians in fact) voted for this outcome in the first place when they approved the new debt limit deal in 2011. At that time everyone agreed that our debt was out of hand and the 60% increase in our national debt was a disgrace ($10 trillion when Bush left office to $16 trillion today). But now that they have to take the medicine they prescribed they are whining like spoiled children. It's even funnier still because both parties sabotaged the bipartisan budget negotiations by demanding things the other side would never accept.

So the question that remains is, how bad is this for our economy? On the one hand, a government budget cut tends to go directly to GDP, just as any spending cut does (either public or private). On the other hand, we have a $15 trillion GDP, so $85 billion is 0.006% (rounded  up) of our GDP. Compare that to the $160 billion dollar Obama tax increase for the 2013 fiscal year, a tax increase Obama has sworn will not affect the economy at all. After all, these budget cuts are almost half the amount of new tax revenue. So if this tax increase (which typically decreases GDP the amount of the increase) won't affect the economy according to our dear leader, why such hew and cry about the smaller sequestration cut? Either he is lying about the tax increase, lying about the budget cuts, or he doesn't understand basic economics.

The real reason for this is obvious, and obviously partisan. Democrats love government spending and high taxes. They hate small government, low budgets and generally allowing anyone who is not living in abject poverty keeping the money they earn. Conversely, while republicans love smaller government (supposedly, I would be remiss in not pointing out that the Bush administration increased the budget and budget deficits as well) they are not generally fans of shrinking our military (or allowing the rest of the world govern themselves without being beholden to our military might).

So which side should we listen to? Neither. It's well known that budget cuts and tax hikes harm economic expansion. It is ludicrous and ludicrously partisan for either side to say otherwise. The silver lining on this whole turd sandwich (mixed metaphor, which should make it easier to understand for beltway insiders) is that neither the tax increase nor the budget cuts are actually large enough to make much difference. What we should be rooting for is stasis. Let both parties paralyze our government, let sequestration go through. It is the first real budget discipline I have seen out of government in my lifetime, which means that it likely will not survive. My hope is that once sequestration goes through and both parties pout like the spoiled children they are, we will see a more serious discussion about budget and tax reform. I doubt this will happen, but I can hope.

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

The Beast Whose Appetite is Never Sated

Now that we as a nation are done with our fight over taxes (the expiration of the Bush tax cuts) with Republicans having capitulated to the Democrats' demands for more revenue, we can lie back, relax, and let the economy recover without further destabilizing government intrusions... HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA!... Didn't know this was a humor blog did you?

No, we are now dealing with the imminent federal budget cuts called sequestration. And shock and awe, the Democrats, lead by our dear leader Obama, are saying that any deal to avert the budget cuts must include... Drum roll please... MORE REVENUE! Who would have thunk it? Turns out that the increase in taxes from Obama Care, the increased taxes in the budget deal, and the increased taxes from letting previous payroll tax cuts expire is not enough new revenue for the Democrats. Nope, they want even more tax revenue. And in typical jack ass, I mean donkey (the symbol of the Democratic party; see, it IS a humor blog), behavior, they are leaving the details up to the Republicans. After all, why get your fingerprints on the evidence of yet more theft from the US tax payers? Fortunately, the Republicans have responded to this appropriately by telling the Democrats to come up with their own deal and that new revenues are off the table (a more appropriate response than what I would have told them).

Lets hope that the Republicans have learned their lesson from the Bush tax cut expiration. Lets hope that this time they will stay united as a party and use the sequestration as the bludgeoning tool it was designed to be to force Democrats to come to the table and actually deal with our budget woes. I won't be holding my breath for this. In all likelihood, neither party will get the other to agree to anything, and sequestration budget cuts will occur as planned. At this point, we should be happy if any fiscal discipline occurs at all.

And this leads me to my greater point, the source of the title of this article, namely that it should now be clear to everyone that no amount of new revenue will ever satisfy the appetites of the left. Or, as Margarette Thatcher once famously said: "Socialist governments traditionally do make a financial mess. They always run out of other peoples' money." To this I would add, that they are always hungry for more. The left has all sorts of grand plans for US tax payers' earnings, but letting us keep them are not among them.

This is why I think it is important for the Republican party to embrace the sequestration budget cuts and use it as a bludgeoning tool against the ravenous left. The left has shown themselves incapable of even a minute amount of budgetary discipline, thus it must be imposed upon them. Because if it is not, this country will become just another bloated first world country with high unemployment, high deficits and be on the verge of economic collapse when international bond markets stop buying our debt.

This will not be an easy task. I fully expect the democrats to pull the old "Think of the children!" histrionics. Be prepared for countless remonstrations about how sequestration will starve the hungry, throw women and children on the streets, and generally do all sorts of horrible things. It will be up to the Republicans to come together as a party and make the case that without sequestration or other budget cuts, our country will be in even worse shape (i.e. we are courting Grecian style economic collapse). Who knows how that debate will come out.